| Unlock all trophies in Mothmen 1966. | 31.60% 珍贵 | |
| Make a creature's accurate drawing. | 57.40% 一般 | |
| Lose with 15 or less cards to go. | 44.10% 珍贵 | |
| Answer properly to an unheard question. | 37.40% 珍贵 | |
|
#10 No secrets Find out Lee's business with Holt. |
54.10% 一般 | |
|
#11 Macho cry Cry your heart out. |
52.90% 一般 | |
| Solve the Winans Piece Puzzle. | 58.40% 一般 | |
|
#13 Puzzle historian Listen about the L's. |
44.70% 珍贵 | |
| Survive all cryptid waves. | 46.90% 珍贵 | |
| Die all possible deaths. | 34.60% 珍贵 | |
| Watch the credits until the end. | 55.10% 一般 | |
| Sort shelves. | 89.30% 一般 | |
| Survive the coyote attack. | 76.00% 一般 | |
| See a winged creature. | 72.50% 一般 | |
| Make a really inaccurate drawing. | 36.10% 珍贵 | |
| Lose with more than 25 cards to go. | 59.10% 一般 |